Fringe, "Subject 13": everything is Olivia's fault

Quick Take: Fringe, "Subject 13"
"You're not her, are you?" - Young Peter

Olivia and Walter in 1985

Review: Fringe, "Subject 13"
(S0315) It's after Peter was kidnapped, and he's all better, but he's suicidal and not taking the transition well. There's enough about his world that's different that he knows something's wrong, and he thinks he can get back by going through the bottom of the frozen lake where he materialized with Walter all those episodes ago. He tries by dropping a cinderblock tied to his waist through the ice in a freaky scene of youthful self-destruction. 

Meanwhile, a young Olivia is being abused by her father and the fear makes her skip to the Other Side for a moment, which drunky-McKid-hitter doesn't seem to notice, but Walter does when she starts to draw pictures of zeppelins. He puts her through a series of tests, trying to determine what emotional trigger will set her off, while a poorly-adjusted Peter wanders around the lab. They start to become friends. Walter discovers that it's fear that triggers her when he gets one of the kids to play dead and she disappears. 

Peter finds her in a field of white tulips (nice reference there, show), and they help eachother cope. When she goes back, though, she's so afraid of getting picked up by her dad that she inadvertently skips back through the universes and explains to Walternate the basics of how everything works. So it's her fault that he knows where Peter is and that there's another version of himself who took him.

This was a nice, tense episode. The young actors playing Olivia and Peter were pretty close to how the adults play them, though Young Peter's gigantic eyes were a little spooky. We got to see how rough it was on Peter's mom, and the beginning of her decline and the start of her marriage dissolving. Apparently, Peter drives people to drink, because we also see Walternate getting well and truly schnockered the whole ep, though this only drives a reconciliation with his wife. Because they're opposites, you see?

It was a good episode, among the best of the season, with all the thoughtfulness that makes Fringe work. But I wanted more. It just seems like they missed the chance to really kick it up  in order to give us little revelations that we've mostly figured out from how people have said things through the rest of the show. I wanted to see Olivia burn up that room and Walter have to shut down the program. I wanted to see the lab at Harvard get gutted and the intern get killed, ruining Walter's rep-- and I wanted it to be because Walternate attempted to bust his way through without a Cortexiphan-doped Olivia. I wanted it all to be his fault, not Walter's. All of this, of course, could come later. There's still at least six episodes of the season. But I feel more and more like there's so much setting-up happening that the end can't possibly live up to it, and if this winds up being their last season (the move to the Death Slot looks like at least someone wants it to be), I fear it'll end on an unsatisfactory note like so many of the shows I love do.

More thoughts on "Subject 13":

  • The 1985 intro is, I think, better than the actual one. The little lists of fringe tech includes things that are common place now, the music is all Cassio-synth, and it's got that wonderful bit of VCR tracking at the end. It's all brilliant.
  • It seems a little convenient that Young Peter and Young Olivia were drawn to each other and that neither remembers it. I mean, I've seen main characters that met as children before (in Doctor Who, season 1; in The Pretender; and in Who's The Boss, off the top of my head), and it stands out as TV shorthand for "they're meant to be" a little too much.
  • You can tell Walternate's office is in Florida because you can see the shuttle there through his window. Even though, at that short distance, his windows would all be blown out every launch. But I bet it's an awesome view.
  • So Olivia can move through space here, as well as through dimensions? I suppose this is a nice, semi-subtle way to introduce that idea, especially if it comes in handy later, but if it doesn't it strikes me as incongruent. Although, I've come to trust these show-makers in the long run, since they always seem to make things that look weird work later.
  • I'd forgotten that Olivia had a violent and abusive father. But where was her sister during this? Were they separated? Was she not born yet?
  • Video: Fringe, "Subject 13"
    Check out the episode in full from Hulu, while available: 

    By Samantha Holloway

    About the author

    Samantha is a freelance writer, editor and book and TV reviewer. She's currently in gradschool and working on her first novel, and one day she'll rule to world. Or marry her TV. Whichever comes first. Follow! twitter.com/pirategirljack.

    More From Samantha Holloway

    "What do you see as the benefit of this?" - Christine
    Read More
    "I'm gonna be a mommy." - Sheldon
    Read More
    1 Comment
    On: Wednesday, March 9, 2011
    Eric - TV Geek Army "Revered Leader" said:

    "a freaky scene of youthful self-destruction."

    Say no more, I'm in !

    Name:

    Email (Will not be used):

    Comment:

    characters left

    Featured

    Popular Today

     
     

    Recent Comments

    Spoiler Alert: I'm about to complain about spoiler alerts
    No matter how careful you are, it's virtually impossible to use any Social Media device or walk into any shop these days without...
    Mad Men, "Christmas Waltz": a plate of spaghetti and a sexy, non-sexual test drive
    I enjoyed every moment of seeing Kinsey back in action again. And I thought the Hari scenes were particularly well done as I somewhat...
    Spoiler Alert: I'm about to complain about spoiler alerts
    Sweet Mary Mother of Peanut Butter, Eric! Can women vote now, as well? Because that would be atrocious. Well put, Love.
    Community: Gillian Jacobs and Jim Rash Answer Burning Questions about the Season [Interview]
    Can you believe the guy is an Academy Award winner? :P Jim Rash has more than earned his star billing in the credits this season...
    Community: Gillian Jacobs and Jim Rash Answer Burning Questions about the Season [Interview]
    Amongst a bevvy of great characters, Dean Pelton is really standout. I love watching Rash / the writers push him into new and weirder...
    America's Got Talent, "Week 1, Night 1" and "Week 1, Night 2": hey now!
    I have a feeling he'll rev up over time. And he did ask that one dude in the first week if his parents died of embarrassment --...
    America's Got Talent, "Week 1, Night 1" and "Week 1, Night 2": hey now!
    Yeah, I get that these kind of shows always have a bunch of crappy contestants for the audition rounds. Usually they're funny, especially...
    America's Got Talent, "Week 1, Night 1" and "Week 1, Night 2": hey now!
    I think an unspoken aspect is having enough novelty-like appeal to at least be amusing for a few more episodes. Donald Trump does...
    America's Got Talent, "Week 1, Night 1" and "Week 1, Night 2": hey now!
    I'm with you. I've watched at least a couple of episodes of each season of AGT, but I'm still not clear on what exactly the criteria...
    America's Got Talent, "Week 1, Night 1" and "Week 1, Night 2": hey now!
    I see your point about Stern's lack of "edge" at times. As a new AGT viewer -- and to your point about the show's failure to launch...
     
     
    Login

    Not a member? Register

    Forgotten Password