Single-Handed Set 1 DVD Review: running to stand still

Picture the most desolate, wind-swept chunk of rural Irish coastline you can fathom. Then imagine you’re the new sheriff in its community, tasked with the mind-numbing grind of keeping the peace in a generally quiet area but also burdened with ferreting out the truth on your own from its insular residents when serious crime occurs. That’s the situation facing Garda Sergeant Jack Driscoll (Owen McDonnell) in the superb Irish drama series Single-Handed. He’s not a total stranger to the area, as he grew up there and is replacing his own father as the top cop, but he’s been away in Dublin for long enough that he’s viewed as an outsider by many of the locals. In the three movie-length episodes presented in this DVD set, he begins to learn his true role, limitations, and the extent he can trust and be trusted.

Single-Handed

Driscoll is a straight arrow at the start of the series, but many of the other folks including his father don’t always have the most noble of intentions or histories. When crime occurs, their natural tendency is to close ranks to protect their own rather than risk public scrutiny and shame. That makes Driscoll’s role even more difficult as he constantly hits brick walls in his investigations. Everybody knows everybody else’s business except outsider Driscoll, keeping the truth one step ahead of him as the residents keep each other informed of his inquiries.

The real pleasure of the series comes from the development of the Driscoll character, making this far more than a brainless CSI:Boondocks crime procedural attempt. The episodic mysteries are fully compelling, but the conflicted character solving them is even more so, making the payoff all the greater when justice is achieved. I was reminded of Kenneth Branagh’s star character in BBC’s excellent Wallander series (and likely the original Swedish version as well, though I haven’t had the pleasure of watching it), as both characters are more interesting than their investigations, pursuing their leads with dogged determination while concurrently dealing with their own internal conflicts. But where Wallander isn’t always the most sympathetic of characters, Driscoll is a shining knight doing his utmost to keep to keep himself and his community on the straight and narrow. Whether he’ll remain so virtuous after prolonged exposure to the community and its idiosyncrasies makes for more than reason enough to follow his ongoing adventures.

Not knowing much about the series, I anticipated some dodgy production values, maybe video quality instead of film, and possibly some obvious soundstage work, but was thrilled to find the episodes to be of theatrical quality and seemingly filmed in entirety on location, another parallel to the Wallander series where the beautiful foreign countryside is as much a character as its inhabitants. The acting is also top-notch, with McDonnell completely owning his lead role and the other locals suitably craggy and hard to read. I was also pleased to find that the Irish brogue is actually quite slight and completely decipherable, although subs are included for anyone needing the extra assistance.

Single-Handed Set 1 is available on DVD on February 1, 2011. It contains the first three feature-length mysteries of the series spread across three discs. There are no bonus features aside from a cursory text interview with the producer and production notes. For more information, visit www.acornonline.com.

By Steve Geise

About the author

Reviewing for various magazines and websites since 2004.

More From Steve Geise

Enhanced video and sound and a new bonus feature are among the improvements over the previous DVD box set
Read More
Outdated image quality, but still a fun trip through a fantasy version of London's underground
Read More
Idris Elba makes a convincing conflicted cop, but with only four episodes the second series is practically over before it starts.
Read More
2 Comments
On: Thursday, January 20, 2011
Eric - TV Geek Army "Revered Leader" said:

This show sounds really great Steve, thanks so much for helping to expose quality programming that may not be on the radar for many of we TV geeks in the U.S. !

On: Friday, January 21, 2011
jaconetan said:

Let me say that the "United Forensic College" is the friendliest, most helpful and accessible college out there right now. The Criminal Justice curriculum isn’t going to overwhelm you.

Name:

Email (Will not be used):

Comment:

characters left

Featured

Popular Today

 
 

Recent Comments

Community Fans: be careful what you wish for
A large portion of Community's fan-base are of the "Harmon or Bust" mindset. I'm going to wait and see how the new season turns...
Spoiler Alert: I'm about to complain about spoiler alerts
No matter how careful you are, it's virtually impossible to use any Social Media device or walk into any shop these days without...
Mad Men, "Christmas Waltz": a plate of spaghetti and a sexy, non-sexual test drive
I enjoyed every moment of seeing Kinsey back in action again. And I thought the Hari scenes were particularly well done as I somewhat...
Spoiler Alert: I'm about to complain about spoiler alerts
Sweet Mary Mother of Peanut Butter, Eric! Can women vote now, as well? Because that would be atrocious. Well put, Love.
Community: Gillian Jacobs and Jim Rash Answer Burning Questions about the Season [Interview]
Can you believe the guy is an Academy Award winner? :P Jim Rash has more than earned his star billing in the credits this season...
Community: Gillian Jacobs and Jim Rash Answer Burning Questions about the Season [Interview]
Amongst a bevvy of great characters, Dean Pelton is really standout. I love watching Rash / the writers push him into new and weirder...
America's Got Talent, "Week 1, Night 1" and "Week 1, Night 2": hey now!
I have a feeling he'll rev up over time. And he did ask that one dude in the first week if his parents died of embarrassment --...
America's Got Talent, "Week 1, Night 1" and "Week 1, Night 2": hey now!
Yeah, I get that these kind of shows always have a bunch of crappy contestants for the audition rounds. Usually they're funny, especially...
America's Got Talent, "Week 1, Night 1" and "Week 1, Night 2": hey now!
I think an unspoken aspect is having enough novelty-like appeal to at least be amusing for a few more episodes. Donald Trump does...
America's Got Talent, "Week 1, Night 1" and "Week 1, Night 2": hey now!
I'm with you. I've watched at least a couple of episodes of each season of AGT, but I'm still not clear on what exactly the criteria...
 
 
Login

Not a member? Register

Forgotten Password