Southland, "U-Boat": patient he is

Quick Take: Southland, "U-Boat"
I've figured out Southland kids. I've cracked the code!

southland

Review: Southland, "U-Boat"
(S0203) It's taken me a while to figure out exactly how I feel about Southland, but I think I finally have it nailed: Southland is a good show that has the potential to be very good and may even occasionally scrape its way to the fringes of great. In terms of the greater television landscape, I call that pretty high praise.

There are two big and obvious problems that I have with the show, and they are both very minor, but they contributed to my not getting a good read on things for some time:

  • The opening theme music / credits are atrocious – That music creeps me out to no end, and seeing old black and white photos of serial killers and the weapons/paraphernalia they used doesn't really fit a gritty, modern show ostensibly about what it's like to be a cop in a big urban city and "live in the gray," as John Cooper (Michael Cudlitz) explains to Ben Sherman (Ben McKenzie) in this episode. Plus, there's the fact that I live in the Southland and the opening credits make me think that there's a psychotic dude with a rusty machete on the perimeter of my lawn at all times, ever watchful. Patient he is.
  • The voiceover / flash forward that kicks off each episode doesn't work – After the credits and the somewhat ominous voiceover and flash forward at the beginning of each episode, I'm ready to think that there's going to be epic carnage and bloodletting. But that doesn't fit the tone at all: documentary-style, hand held camera, no soundtrack, and emphasis on realism.
  • I really think if they simply dropped these two elements (a silent shot of the Southland logo with a shot of LA in the background would work just fine, I'd say) the show would be framed much better for what it does best.

    All of that aside, this was a pretty good episode because it showcases the two best characters (John and Ben) at their best. Ben's first day riding solo was particularly engaging and dramatic, running the gamut from single-handedly finding a young Korean girl with Asperger's who had "wandered off" to a brutal confrontation with a celebrity chef-turned-stalker. (The fact that Ben got the bad guy just after he did his worst says a lot about the direction and integrity of the show.)

    The Rene (Amaury Nolasco) and Lydia (Regina King) pairing is growing on me as well. Rene brings some humor and spice into the mix and warms up Lydia, who has been fairly dour and serious in the past.

    The official show recap (below) references Gil Puente (Laz Alonso) working on taking down Trinny Day (Wood Harris, he of highest The Wire fame), but that must have been cut out of this episode late or moved to a different one. Maybe that's why the name of the episode doesn't make a lot of sense to me either (apart from the notion of a submarine that can pop up and cause havoc at any time?), but maybe I missed a small detail.

    Video: Southland, "U-Boat"
    Here's the episode recap, from TNT:

    Recap: Southland, "U-Boat"
    Ben winds up in a patrol unit alone for the first time. Among the cases he has to handle on his own are a missing girl and a suspected stalking case. Lydia and Rene spend the day checking in on and helping out Brianna and her baby. Over in Gangs, Gil Puente leads the task force to take down ex-banger Trinny Day, but Sal and Sammy have a hard time working with Puente. While patrolling with John, it is clear that Chickie has no command presence, but she is determined to work harder and become a good cop again.

    From Around the Web: Southland, "U-Boat"

  • The Graveyard Shift : There’s not a more exciting day for a rookie than the day when they’re finally allowed to set out on their own. They gladly allow their training officers to nudge them from their nests, sending them out to meet the day, wide-eyed and anxious to save the world. Everything looks different to them that day. The sun is brighter. The sirens are louder. And cockiness is at its peak.
  • By Eric - TV Geek Army "Revered Leader"

    About the author

    Eric is the publisher and revered leader of TV Geek Army… at least in his own mind. TV Geek Army is a place for serious TV reviews and news for serious fans of great television. Contact: eric-[at]-tvgeekarmy.com 

    More From Eric - TV Geek Army "Revered Leader"

    Now that Paul Kinsey (Michael Gladis) made a brief but splashy and phenomenal return during last night's Mad Men episode, "Christmas Waltz," there remains only one significant advertising pro from the early seasons who has not made an appearance in the Sterling Cooper Draper Pryce era.
    Read More
    I had to check in to see how The King of All Media would do in his new digs.
    Read More
    My first thought was: "Sounds pretty good, will definitely check it out when it makes air." But then the Bigger Picture came into play.
    Read More
    0 Comments
    Name:

    Email (Will not be used):

    Comment:

    characters left

    Featured

    Popular Today

     
     

    Recent Comments

    Community Fans: be careful what you wish for
    A large portion of Community's fan-base are of the "Harmon or Bust" mindset. I'm going to wait and see how the new season turns...
    Spoiler Alert: I'm about to complain about spoiler alerts
    No matter how careful you are, it's virtually impossible to use any Social Media device or walk into any shop these days without...
    Mad Men, "Christmas Waltz": a plate of spaghetti and a sexy, non-sexual test drive
    I enjoyed every moment of seeing Kinsey back in action again. And I thought the Hari scenes were particularly well done as I somewhat...
    Spoiler Alert: I'm about to complain about spoiler alerts
    Sweet Mary Mother of Peanut Butter, Eric! Can women vote now, as well? Because that would be atrocious. Well put, Love.
    Community: Gillian Jacobs and Jim Rash Answer Burning Questions about the Season [Interview]
    Can you believe the guy is an Academy Award winner? :P Jim Rash has more than earned his star billing in the credits this season...
    Community: Gillian Jacobs and Jim Rash Answer Burning Questions about the Season [Interview]
    Amongst a bevvy of great characters, Dean Pelton is really standout. I love watching Rash / the writers push him into new and weirder...
    America's Got Talent, "Week 1, Night 1" and "Week 1, Night 2": hey now!
    I have a feeling he'll rev up over time. And he did ask that one dude in the first week if his parents died of embarrassment --...
    America's Got Talent, "Week 1, Night 1" and "Week 1, Night 2": hey now!
    Yeah, I get that these kind of shows always have a bunch of crappy contestants for the audition rounds. Usually they're funny, especially...
    America's Got Talent, "Week 1, Night 1" and "Week 1, Night 2": hey now!
    I think an unspoken aspect is having enough novelty-like appeal to at least be amusing for a few more episodes. Donald Trump does...
    America's Got Talent, "Week 1, Night 1" and "Week 1, Night 2": hey now!
    I'm with you. I've watched at least a couple of episodes of each season of AGT, but I'm still not clear on what exactly the criteria...
     
     
    Login

    Not a member? Register

    Forgotten Password