Doctor Who, "A Christmas Carol": a little too tried and true

Quick Take: Doctor Who, "A Christmas Carol"
Doctor Who’s 2010 Christmas special is an uneven piece filled with brilliant ideas that just doesn't quite make the grade on the emotion.

a christmas carol

Review: Doctor Who, "A Christmas Carol"
To say I was looking forward to the first Stephen Moffat Christmas special would have been an understatement of epic proportions.  The previous Christmas specials have all been exceptionally varied in their quality, some have been a lot of fun if not exactly deep (like Tenant's first outing -- "The Christmas Invasion" and "The Run Away Bride") while some have been just awful ("Voyage of the Damned," which wasn't even saved by having Clive Rowe in it).

But, the change of the writer at the helm from Russell T. Davies to Stephen Moffat had proven to be a great thing, as over the latest season both Moffat and Matt Smith (as the Eleventh Doctor) won me over with some incredible stories, ranging from hugely emotional pieces all the way to fun, nonsensical romps that were so entertaining you could overlook the weaker moments.

There were some things to love about "A Christmas Carol" as it was a story filled with inventive moments and clever spoofs.  I enjoyed the crisp white semi-Star Trek bridge in the opening moments, and the humour of Amy and Rory stumbling in from the honeymoon suite dressed as a "kiss-a-gram" police woman and a Roman soldier respectively was both a nice nod to the previous season's events and a fun knowing moment for those of us old enough to "get" what the pair had been planning to get up to.  It's a shame Doctor Who is a family show, considering Moffat's humour, as we could have ended up with their costumes reversed!

The setting for the vast majority of the episode was not on the ship, but in a semi-futuristic, semi-steampunk city that echoed the times of Dickens's A Christmas Carol in Prose (more commonly known as A Christmas Carol) while also giving everything a science fiction tint.  In particular the concept of fish "swimming" through the air resulted in some memorable scenes -- especially the ones involving the shark.

The sonic screwdriver was used in a new but believable fashion, there was plenty of fun with time (even if it will cause some people's heads to explode), and Matt Smith was charming and entertaining throughout the story.

But.

But while the concept was great, having a story riff off Dickens' classic tale is a tried and true Christmas concept, and the entire thing just felt a little flat. It was exciting at times, but Amy and Rory just never felt like they were in danger.  Likewise the character of Kazran Sardic fell very flat as well -- despite being the central point to the story it was hard to either like him or care about what happens to him.

The most exciting moment came when the Doctor ended up face-to-tooth with the shark and if the special had had more moments like that it would have become something really great.  Instead it moved off in a more emotion-driven direction, which could have paid off very well -- the love affair between Kazran and Abigal (Katherine Jenkins) spanning decades of Christmas Eves being a sweet concept. 

The thing is, Rusty (Russell T. Davies) might not have been the best science fiction writer for Doctor Who, but he knew how to sell emotional stories and scenes with great expertise.  It's surprising that Moffat can't get the notes right here, because his past work with Coupling (and Doctor Who) has shown a deft ability to pen stories that are fun, believable, well plotted and always hitting the right notes for the characters (the end of Coupling is a superb example of this skill).

It's possible that here he's been hamstrung by the decision to loosely follow A Christmas Carol. The predictability of the plot and the corniness of the ending seem to undermine Moffat's strengths and I can't help but feel he may have been better off going for a more subversive take on the concept instead of sticking to something that is very traditional in its style.

In the end, this year's Christmas special is just not a great piece of work. It has good ideas and fun moments, but the overall execution is lacking.  It should have been an exciting tale of magic, love, and daring, but instead it ended up being rather ordinary and even boring at times.  It was not anywhere near as bad as either "Voyage of the Damned" or "Love and Monsters," but it won't end up being an all time classic Doctor Who story.

By Fen

About the author

Used to blog over at http://rev-views.blogspot.com/ but have since migrated here to TV Geek Army!

More From Fen

In our look at The Shield's second season we consider the characterization of bureaucracy, the existence of criminal money trains and the growth of Ronnie Gardocki.
Read More
The first in a multi-part retrospective look at Shawn Ryan's seminal police drama The Shield.
Read More
TVGA's Masterwork column this week looks at one of the landscape television shows of the last ten years, a show that redefined quality drama and attitudes towards death. Of course it is Six Feet Under.
Read More
0 Comments
Name:

Email (Will not be used):

Comment:

characters left
 

Featured Articles

Popular Today

 
 

Recent Comments

Parks and Recreation: why is everyone so mean to Jerry?
I just finished the series on Netflix and can not wrap my mind around how he is treated. I never found humor in any of the scenes...
Swamp People, "It's Personal": men at work
Wow, very hard work , 1st they are hooked with a hook in there mouth , 2nd they come along with a shot gun and shoots it in the...
Stitchers: everything changes in the finale, "All In"
I think something is up with Nina--to me, it looked like something just occurred to her and she got up to go do it or find out about...
Stitchers: everything changes in the finale, "All In"
Am I the only one who thinks that something bad is going to happen to Nina based on the brief cut of her during Cameron's closing...
My Last Days: powerful documentary airs on the CW Network
I received a wonderful compliment from Justin Baldoni in regard to this article, he said, "Wow thank you for this beautiful article...
Hoarders: Buried Alive, "Stop Touching My Stuff!": my kind of clean
I have lost people greatly I've had severe depression since 12 I'm 43.luckily for me I was not a harder. This was the first show...
Hoarders: Buried Alive, "Stop Touching My Stuff!": my kind of clean
Poor kid has serious mental health issues!!! Haley needs help!!!
12 Monkeys: The end of the season is a "Memory of Tomorrow" and it'll blow your mind!
At this point, it's not what the writers CAN do with a time-travel story, it's what they will do to make it satisfying and legendary...
12 Monkeys: The end of the season is a "Memory of Tomorrow" and it'll blow your mind!
Cole could definitely use a collection of photos of everyone he's ever met to show to people, that's for sure! I don't know if they...