Project Runway, "Off the Track": quitters, tripping, and butt toe

Quick Take: Project Runway, “Off the Track”
“They’re dropping like flies on Project Runway” – Tim Gunn

PR 5

Review: Project Runway, “Off the Track”
(S0905) I really hate reality show quitters.

Yes, I know you don’t really know what it’s like to walk in someone else’s shoes until you’ve walked a mile in them yourself, but I do know what it takes to get through the casting process for a reality show. If you can make it through that gauntlet and not back out, then I have no sympathy for you when your ego is hurt or you can’t stand the heat in the proverbial kitchen while on the show. Cecilia was emotionally decimated from being on the chopping block last episode but not getting sent home. So she wakes up the next morning looking beat down and totally out of the game. She’s got no drive, no emotion in her face and she’s obviously mentally checked out. When she’s asked to suit up in track gear with the rest of the competitors, it’s like someone asked her to kick a puppy. When they’re all tasked to line up for a foot race to determine team captains for the next challenge, Cecilia walks over to Tim and Heidi and sends herself packing. Everyone looks a little shocked, but the luckily there was no coddling Cecilia to get her to stay. Tim and Heidi made sure she knew what she was giving up and then they told her to leave. Good. If you quit, be gone with you in my book. You wasted a slot for someone that could have gone the distance.

As mentioned, the challenge was all about active wear, specifically Heidi’s line of sportswear for New Balance. The designers were tasked to create three fashion looks based on a pair of her New Balance shoes, using denim and/or suede. The models had to wear the shoes with the outfit and the winner would get their design manufactured and sold via Amazon as part of the NB line. The designers were jazzed…until they were told they had to compete in teams again. Immediately the “NO BERT” light went on for several of the designers and it wasn’t lost on bitchy Bert either. Winners of the foot race were Joshua, Bryce, Anthony and Victor.

Joshua chose Anya and Becky. Bryce selected Kim and Danielle. Anthony picked Laura and got Bert by default (last one standing). Victor got Oliver and the momentous task of picking one previous bootee to come back into the show to replace Cecilia and be on his team. He selected Josh C with the approval of the other designers.

All four teams got together to sketch their ideas and of course Bert didn’t gel with Anthony or Laura which meant tension city from the get-go. Surprisingly, Joshua also came off like a complete jerk by marginalizing Becky to her face saying her work was “dowdy” and he didn’t want her design input at all. He just wanted her to sew what he told her to sew. It was harsh and mean and very unbecoming to a future design professional. He even brought Becky to tears and yelled at her about it. He tried to patch it up later by apologizing but his behavior earned him a bully label in perpetuity. Shame, shame Joshua!

Heidi and Tim both oversaw the initial team consultations and they were not pleased. Heidi pretty much ripped every team for their lackluster designs. Matter of fact, she was so concerned that she even extended the 11pm scissors down deadline to 4 am so they could fix their messes.

On the runway, Erin Wasson, model and designer, joined Heidi, Michael Kors and Nina Garcia to judge the teams.  After all the behind-the-scenes drama, Joshua, Bryce and Victor’s teams all got major kudos for leadership and mostly good collections. Anthony’s team was cited for the most dysfunction in terms of design as well as designer drama which meant a lack of cohesion. Bert went after Anthony and Laura for their bad design and it got ugly on stage. However, the judges liked Bert’s look the best of the three. Even Anthony conceded his work was crap.

Joshua got called out by Becky for his behavior and the judges were unhappy to hear it, but they felt like his artistic vision made the collection stand out overall. In the end, the judges made a surprise move and awarded Joshua and Victor a dual win (and immunity) on the strength of their looks. Hmmm, I guess the mean guy prospered this round. Shame, shame again!

On the chopping block was Danielle for another silky top with no originality or vision and Anthony’s mess of an outfit that gave the model both camel toe and butt toe. Turns out the majority voted out Danielle for her lack of inspiring work to date, which Heidi disagreed with. She would have axed Anthony, but he lived to sew another day. 

By Tara Bennett

About the author

is an author (The Lost Encyclopedia), a national entertainment journalist and a media studies adjunct professor at Rowan University. She's been a film, TV and pop culture junkie for as long as she can remember and she's got the old TV Guide's to prove it. Pray for her thighs as she spends far too much time at her desk writing or her couch watching what she loves.

More From Tara Bennett

Creator Bryan Fuller and star Hugh Dancy share some tasty insight on their brand new horror series.
Read More
Community ends the season with three brand new episodes tonight and the actors talk about the show's renewal.
Read More
We make a case for The Hunger Games sequel going to a TV director.
Read More
1 Comment
On: Friday, August 26, 2011
Eric - TV Geek Army "Revered Leader" said:

butt toe, uh oh !

Name:

Email (Will not be used):

Comment:

characters left

Featured Shows

 
 

Featured Articles

Popular Today

 

Recent Comments

Family Tools, "Now You See Me, Now You Don't": the art of disappearing
Guess the author of this article didn't hear that Family Tools has already been cancelled and tonight's episode has been pulled...
Parks and Recreation: why is everyone so mean to Jerry?
I can respect the opinion that you don't like the running gag in regards to Jerry, but at least recognize that he is hardly the...
Parks and Recreation: why is everyone so mean to Jerry?
I think everyone's attitude toward Jerry makes sense within the deliciously oddball universe that is Parks and Recreation. It's...
Supernatural, "The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo": Revenge of the nerds
felicia day is one of the most overrated people in tv/film... if she didnt pretend to be a geeky girl, no one would even give 2...
Mad Men: a new coup at Sterling Cooper Draper Pryce?
certainly we saw some of don's ugliest traits come out in this episode!
Mad Men: a new coup at Sterling Cooper Draper Pryce?
I hate when the depressed, cheating scum Don is around. He is being such a jerk to Megan and she doesnt deserve it. His hypocritical...
Hannibal: 5 Things You Need to Know for the Season [Interview]
First, Fuller is one of the truly unique and great minds working in television today, so it's always exciting to see him roll out...
The Americans "Safe House": irony of all ironies
In regards to your Kramer vs. Kramer comment... Yup, you are right it was a time when divorce was more socially acceptable. I recall...
The Americans "Safe House": irony of all ironies
I had a few odd realizations while watching the episode. First is that this was the era of Kramer vs. Kramer. Not sure if that means...