The X Factor, "Final Judges Cut": and the best mentor is... Paula Abdul?

Quick Take: The X Factor, "Final Judges Cut"
"Tonight you were like a racing driver and L.A. (Reid) put you in a tractor." - Simon Cowell

Review: The X Factor, "Final Judges Cut"
(S0111) Last night The X Factor judges dismissed the final contestants, leaving it up to America from here on out and I must say, America's got some pretty tough decisions to make. Overall, the level of talent on The X Factor is leaps and bounds above American Idol, The Voice, and just about any other singing competition out there. I have been really, really impressed.

So let's get started dissecting the night's events. But first I need to mention how much I like host Steve Jones. He actually keeps the show moving along, unlike Ryan Seacrest who spends more time heckling the judges and drawing out long pauses than he does, well, actually hosting. Plus he's easy on the eyes and I'm a sucker for that accent. Props Mr. Jones!

Also, Simon decided to dress up for the occasion, ditching his usual v-neck tee and instead opted for a dress shirt and suit jacket. Of course it was still unbuttoned enough to reveal his signature man-cleavage, but hey, that's his style.

Now onto the acts. L.A. Reid and the boys were up first. Here's a breakdown:

1. Astro - He's the cocky 14 year-old from Brooklyn who rapped about his mom during the audition rounds. Now I usually really hate little kid singers trying to act like adults, but even I have to admit this kid is good. The judges loved him and after that performance I knew he was a sure thing.

2. Chris Rene - Another rapper who got off to a great start in the audition rounds, Chris sang a slower song last night and it was only okay. He has a nice voice, but it came across a little weak during the performance. The rapping sections were where he truly shined.

3. Phillip Lomax - This confident crooner looked like he was on his way to the prom, from the three-piece suit to the carnation on his lapel. It was a little cheesy and the song choice and choreography didn't help.

4. Marcus Canty - The vocals were pretty solid, but the performance needed some work. It was very Sister Act 2: Back in the Habit. I almost expected Whoopi Goldberg to emerge stage right and hand him the big trophy.

L.A.'s verdict: Bye bye Phillip Lomax!

Next to perform were Paula's groups, prompting some of the best reviews, particularly from Simon who praised Paula twice. Let's recap:

1. Stereo Hogzz - The vocals were really good, especially the lead, but the crazy dance moves (most notably one that looked like a Native American rain dance) were a little distracting.

2. Brewer Boys - These sweet brothers from wine country were like country acoustic Biebers singing at the local church hoedown retreat jamboree. It was wholesome and cute and little girls across America were probably dancing in front of their television sets swooning.

3. Intensity - This ten person group was formed by pulling solo acts together. It was like watching Mickey Mouse Club 2.0. I didn't hate it, but I didn't love it either. The group sounded really great together, but alone, a few of the singers were not good, especially that first girl.

4. Lakoda Rayne - Another group to be put together after the auditions, these four girls really sounded superb. The song choice was a little weird ("Come on Ilene") but somehow it worked. L.A. said he would sign them in an instant and Simon was really impressed. If they continue on in the competition at this level, this is the group to beat.

Paula's verdict: A tearful goodbye to the Brewer Boys.

Third to go were Nicole and the Over 30s. Here's the rundown:

1. Dexter Haygood - This performance was very forgettable. Too much yelling, weird choreography, weirder song choice. I don't think I would buy a Dexter Haygood album. Sorry.

2. Leroy Bell - The 60-year old singer, who I have to point out, doesn't look a day over 42, has a strong, soulful voice. If you closed your eyes he sounded just like Michael Bolton. Good thing or bad thing? I'll let you decide.

3. Stacy Francis - The only female in the category, Stacy let her inner-diva shine. She has a great voice, but I can't connect with her personality. Maybe it's because she's crying all the time.

4. Josh Krajick - Ahh, my dark horse, who I called out as the frontrunner the second I saw him perform. Well, he slayed it yet again! Simon actually said that Josh was the one act that he was afraid. Yep, he's that good.

Nicole's verdict: Sorry Dexter Haygood. You're out.

Finally it was the girls and Simon. Last week we watched as Simon made a terrible mistake and cut fan favorite Melanie Amarao. So last night Mr. Cowell had to say farewell to two girls. Here's how everyone stacked up:

1. Simone Battle - There's no denying the girl's got the look of a superstar, but her vocals just aren't on par with the rest of the singers. She took a lot of criticism from the other judges (L.A. was even a little mean), but Simon still thought she did well.

2. Rachel Crow - This pint size singer was clearly a fan favorite and she easily put the previous contestant to shame. Simon labeled her retro pop and Nicole called her "my little Miss Sunshine."

3. Drew - Holy cow! I can't believe this girl is only 14 years-old. Her rendition of "What a Feeling" was stripped down and so hauntingly beautiful it gave me chills. Drew definitely has a place in the finals.

4. Tiah Tolliver - Poor Tiah. She had already divided the judges during the audition rounds and you knew that Paula and Nicole were already dissecting her even before she sang a single note. The performance was waaay over the top, which was probably done to hide her weak voice. Nicole summed it up pretty well when she said "if that was a sweet dream, I'd hate to see a bad nightmare."

5. Melanie Amaro - Simon dropped the ball when he cut Melanie last week. Thank goodness he came to his senses and brought her back! Melanie has such a powerful voice and out of all the singing competition shows, she's the only one I've ever heard who could hold her own with a Whitney Houston song.

Simon's verdict: Adios Simone Battle and Tiah Tolliver.

Overall the show was enjoyable to watch and I'm excited to see how my favorites perform throughout the remaining live shows. Another cool element to look forward to is the introduction of Twitter in the voting process and you can bet I'll be ready with #drew and #joshkrajick.

By Kirby_Reed

About the author

Kirby Reed is an aspiring author and freelance writer with a rabid pop culture obsession. She's currently in love with 'Game of Thrones' and has two little 'direwolves' of her own.

Follow her on Twitter! @popculturepup

More From Kirby_Reed

The Maria Bello cop drama ends its first, and likely final season after just 13 episodes.
Read More
Tensions boil over between Lisa and Taylor.
Read More
The racers touch down in Copenhagen where two teams must complete both sides of the detour after suffering the dreaded double u-turn.
Read More
On: Thursday, October 27, 2011
Adam said:

I completely disagree with you. Dexter Haygood is a great singer and was the most compelling and charismatic performer of the bunch.  Sure, he was given a song choice so odd that it almost seemed like an act of sabotage, but still managed to give an entertaining and professional performance with it.  Frankly, your attack against him is completely clueless -- FAIL.

On: Thursday, October 27, 2011
Kirby_Reed said:

Hi Adam and thanks for the comment.

I didn't think I attacked Dexter in this post, but if you took it that way, I'm sorry. I think I was so distracted by the song choice and backup dancers that for me, Dexter's vocal talents were overshadowed.

I saw Dexter's first audition and was really rooting for him. He has a good voice and I can sympathize with his personal story. I missed all the episodes in between, so when I saw this most recent performance I was surprised at the direction Nicole took him. You're totally right, it did seem like an act of sabotage. So again, I'm not a Dexter hater, I just didn't like that performance.


Email (Will not be used):


characters left

Featured Articles

Popular Today


Recent Comments

Parks and Recreation: why is everyone so mean to Jerry?
I just finished the series on Netflix and can not wrap my mind around how he is treated. I never found humor in any of the scenes...
Swamp People, "It's Personal": men at work
Wow, very hard work , 1st they are hooked with a hook in there mouth , 2nd they come along with a shot gun and shoots it in the...
Stitchers: everything changes in the finale, "All In"
I think something is up with Nina--to me, it looked like something just occurred to her and she got up to go do it or find out about...
Stitchers: everything changes in the finale, "All In"
Am I the only one who thinks that something bad is going to happen to Nina based on the brief cut of her during Cameron's closing...
My Last Days: powerful documentary airs on the CW Network
I received a wonderful compliment from Justin Baldoni in regard to this article, he said, "Wow thank you for this beautiful article...
Hoarders: Buried Alive, "Stop Touching My Stuff!": my kind of clean
I have lost people greatly I've had severe depression since 12 I'm 43.luckily for me I was not a harder. This was the first show...
Hoarders: Buried Alive, "Stop Touching My Stuff!": my kind of clean
Poor kid has serious mental health issues!!! Haley needs help!!!
12 Monkeys: The end of the season is a "Memory of Tomorrow" and it'll blow your mind!
At this point, it's not what the writers CAN do with a time-travel story, it's what they will do to make it satisfying and legendary...
12 Monkeys: The end of the season is a "Memory of Tomorrow" and it'll blow your mind!
Cole could definitely use a collection of photos of everyone he's ever met to show to people, that's for sure! I don't know if they...
12 Monkeys: The end of the season is a "Memory of Tomorrow" and it'll blow your mind!
Can you imagine a scene between Aaron Stanford and Amanda Schull like in Chinatown? I'm your daughter. I'm your mother. I'm your...